Want to get into options, but too afraid of the inherent risks? 

Fear not, for the protective collar is here! This financial superhero stands vigilant, safeguarding all the innocent assets in your portfolio. But this strategy doesn’t just serve as a defensive shield; it’s a calculated move blending the worlds of owned stock, purchased put options, and sold call options. 

Masterfully employed, the protective collar acts as both guardian and guide, protecting you from severe market downturns and ensuring potential upside gains. Dive into the following sections as we explore the mechanics of this protector of portfolios, and discover how it can be an indispensable ally in your investment journey.

What is a Protective Collar?

Diving into the diverse realm of options trading, we come across the protective collar. It’s a strategic move designed to shield an investor’s stock from steep losses while also leaving some room for potential gains. Breaking it down, a protective collar is a three-step dance: you own the stock, buy put options, and sell call options.

The main goal of this collar is to reign in the risks when the market gets a bit wild. If you have a long position in a stock, there’s always that niggling fear of its price dropping. Here’s where the put option comes into play. By buying it, an investor secures the right to sell their stock at a fixed price, the strike price. Think of it as setting a safety net, ensuring losses don’t spiral beyond a certain point.

Now, buying that safety net (the put option) isn’t free. To counterbalance this expense, the investor sells a call option. This move gives another trader the chance to buy the stock at a set price. While this does place a ceiling on how high your profits can soar, the money from selling that call option offsets the cost of the put option. These three actions—holding the stock, buying a put, and selling a call—craft the protective collar.

Think of using a protective collar as equipping your stock with a reliable life jacket, allowing you to navigate the turbulent waters of the stock market. While it provides a cushion against sudden declines in stock value, it still allows for potential upward price movements. A prime example of its utility would be employing it with Ford’s stock before it tumbled following the United Auto Workers strike

Simply put, it’s like getting insurance for your stock investments. It shields against the market’s unpredictable swings, making it a go-to for those who aim to guard their capital yet still dip their toes in the lively world of options trading. 

Understand How Protective Collar Works

The protective collar strategy is a savvy technique in options trading that melds three core elements: owning the stock in question, buying a put option, and selling a call option. Let’s delve into how these pieces fit together to create a secure shield for an investor’s stock position.

Step 1: Own the Stock

First things first: have a long position in the stock. This simply means the investor holds the company’s shares and is keenly interested in how they fare in the marketplace.

Step 2: Opt for a Put Option

Then, purchase a put option for that stock. Here’s the deal with a put option: it grants the investor the right (without being obligated) to sell a certain amount of stock at a fixed price, dubbed the strike price, within a certain timeframe. Picture this put option as your financial safety net. If the stock’s price takes a nosedive below the strike price, the investor can spring into action, using the option to sell the stock at the predetermined rate, curbing deeper losses.

Step 3: Pitch a Call Option

To balance the books from the put option purchase, it’s time to sell a call option for the same stock. What’s a call option? It’s a ticket that lets the buyer snap up the stock at an agreed price within a set period. By offloading this call option, you create what’s known as a short call option, and the investor bags a premium, which can go towards offsetting the put option’s cost. But here’s the catch: if the stock’s price shoots past the call option’s strike price, the investor must sell the stock at that rate, setting a ceiling on potential profits.

Stringing these steps together, the protective collar strategy acts as a financial buffer against significant losses, yet leaves room for potential gains within set boundaries. It’s an ideal solution for investors seeking protection from market upheavals, as seen in the recent energy market fluctuations, while still eager to capitalize on favorable price movements. In essence, the protective collar epitomizes the versatility and strategic sophistication of options trading, catering to those adopting a prudent investment approach.

Constructing Protective Collars

Building a protective collar involves some essential steps that traders need to navigate with precision to maximize its hedging potential. Let’s walk through the process of crafting a protective collar:

  1. Examine Your Stock Portfolio: First off, take a good look at your stock holdings. Determine which stocks you’re keen to hedge with the protective collar approach. Your decision should be rooted in a solid evaluation of each stock’s track record, current market trends, and anticipated future shifts.
  2. Acquire the Target Stock: If it’s not already in your portfolio, snap up the shares of the stock you’re looking to shield. This ownership is your starting point for the protective collar game plan.
  3. Spot the Right Put Option: Choose a put option that matches your hedging goals. Key things to zero in on? The expiration date and the strike price. Ideally, the strike price of the put option should hover near or just under the stock’s current price, giving you that all-important safety buffer against downside surprises.
  4. Get that Put Option: Purchase the chosen put option. Keep in mind, its price tag will vary based on aspects like the chosen strike price, how long until it expires, and the stock’s volatility.
  5. Pick Out the Call Option: Seek out a call option that has a strike price sitting above the stock’s present value. You’ll be selling this option to counterbalance the cost of the put option. Choose the call option’s strike price based on how much profit ceiling you’re comfortable setting.
  6. Sell the Call Option: Sell the selected call option. The funds you rake in from this sale will help counteract the money shelled out for the put option.
  7. Stay Alert and Tweak as Needed: After you’ve got your protective collar in place, don’t go on autopilot. Stay tuned to how your stock performs and be ready to adjust your strategy based on the market’s mood swings and any shifts in your risk appetite.

By nailing these steps and weighing all the factors, traders can design a protective collar that acts as a financial guardrail against unexpected losses, while still keeping the window open for profit within set limits. It’s a strategic move especially suited for those wanting a calm passage through the sometimes stormy seas of volatile markets.

Earnings and Losses with Protective Collar

Diving into the protective collar strategy? It’s vital to grasp the potential profits and setbacks tied to it. Essentially, a protective collar aims to shield you from sharp downturns like the recent S&P 500 correction, while granting you some room to ride the profit wave. Let’s dissect the ins and outs of the earnings and losses of this tactic.

Dynamics of Earnings and Losses

The balance of wins and losses in a protective collar is influenced by the chosen strike prices and how the stock behaves. While put options act as your financial safety harness, capping potential dips, selling call options puts a lid on your profit potential. The real-time earnings or hits to your pocket hinge on where the stock price stands when the options expire.

Before getting into the specifics, here’s a visual of how the protective collar realizes profits and incurs losses: 

Payoff diagram illustrating the profit and loss range of a protective collar strategy.

Graphical breakdown of the collar option strategy: A combined view of both the protective downside and capped upside.

This graph showcases the protective nature of the collar strategy, setting clear boundaries for potential gains and losses. A visual of this strategy’s performance clearly shows the balance it strikes between risk mitigation and profit potential. Now let’s get into the specifics. 

Maximum Profit:

The ceiling on your profit in a protective collar is set by the strike price of the call option you sell. If the stock price soars past the call option’s strike price, your max earnings equal the gap between the stock’s price and the call option’s strike price, adjusted by the net premium from initiating the collar.

Max Profit = (Strike Price of Call Option − Stock Purchase Price) − Net Premium Max Profit = (Strike Price of Call Option − Stock Purchase Price) − Net Premium

Maximum Loss:

Your biggest potential setback is anchored by the strike price of the put option you buy. Should the stock’s price tumble below this point, your maximum loss equals the difference between your buying price for the stock and the put option’s strike price, tweaked by the net premium from the collar setup.

Max Loss = (Stock Purchase Price − Strike Price of Put Option) + Net Premium Max Loss = (Stock Purchase Price − Strike Price of Put Option) + Net Premium

Hitting the Break-Even:

The equilibrium point for the protective collar is the stock’s buying price, adjusted by the net premium from its setup. If you end up pocketing a net premium (when the call option’s premium outdoes the one for the put option), the break-even is your stock’s purchase price less the net premium. If you’re out of pocket for the net premium, then add it to the stock’s purchase price.

Break-Even Point = Stock Purchase Price ± Net PremiumBreak-Even Point = Stock Purchase Price±Net Premium

To wrap it up, the protective collar offers a safety net while giving you a shot at profits. Exact results, whether gains or losses, are tied to the stock’s price shifts and your option strike prices. With judicious strike price choices and a keen eye on stock performance, traders can fine-tune this strategy to match their risk comfort and market predictions. 

Example of Protective Collar

Let’s walk through a practical example to get a clearer grasp on the protective collar strategy. Picture an investor with 100 shares of Ford (F), with its stock priced at $10 each. While they’re optimistic about the company’s long-term trajectory, they’re a bit wary about short-term dips over the next couple of months because of recent concerns about the EV market.

Here’s how the protective collar gets set up:

  • Put Option Purchase: The investor secures a two-month put option for F at a strike price of $9. This costs them a premium of $0.20 for each share, summing up to $20 for all 100 shares.
  • Call Option Sale: To counterbalance the put option’s cost, our investor offloads a two-month call option on F, with a strike price of $11. This fetches them a premium of $0.20 per share, which translates to $20 for their 100 shares.

Now, let’s navigate through the possible outcomes after this two-month period:

Scenario 1: Stock Dips to $8

Thanks to the put option, our investor has the privilege to offload their shares at $9, thus narrowing down their losses. The call option becomes irrelevant and fades away. The final result? They get $9 for each share, with the net premium being a neutral $0 (so, effectively $9 a share).

Scenario 2: Stock Surges to $12

The call option gets activated, compelling the investor to part with their shares at $11 each. Meanwhile, the put option becomes redundant. Here, the endgame is them pocketing $11 for each share, once again adjusted by a net zero premium (making it precisely $11 a share).

Scenario 3: Stock Remains Steady at $10

In this case, both options fizzle out without any action. The shares remain with the investor, and the value remains untouched, with the net premium being a flat $0 (hence, it stays $10 a share).

To sum it up, this protective collar strategy has neatly crafted a floor at $9 and a ceiling at $11 for our investor. With the premiums canceling each other out, these thresholds stand firm. This approach has not only thrown in a safety layer against drastic drops but also carved out a space for some profit. Plus, the investor is still in the game for any long-term upsides by retaining the shares.

Pros and Cons of Protective Collar

The protective collar strategy has found favor with many option traders due to its ability to provide a safety net against sharp declines in stock prices while offering potential profit avenues. But as with all financial strategies, it brings with it both advantages and disadvantages. Here’s a breakdown:


  • Downside Shield: Topping the list of pros is the defensive nature of this strategy. With the acquisition of a put option, traders cement a base level beyond which they won’t suffer any further loss, irrespective of how far the stock price might plummet.
  • Budget-Friendly: One of the appeals of a protective collar is that it can be set up at a minimal net cost. The premium earned from the sold call option often neutralizes, if not exceeds, the premium paid for the put option.
  • Adaptability: The protective collar is not a one-size-fits-all tactic. Traders have the liberty to select expiration dates and strike prices tailored to their unique risk appetite and market predictions.


  • Capped Earnings: Just as some strategies like the covered call inherently come with limited gains due to their structure, the protective collar strategy limits maximum profit. If the stock price skyrockets, traders may have to sell their shares at the sold call option’s strike price, missing out on higher market rates.
  • Intricacy: This isn’t a strategy you dive into without adequate preparation. Dealing with both put and call options necessitates a solid grasp of options trading. It can be intricate, and there’s a steep learning curve for those unfamiliar with the terrain.
  • Missed Chances: There’s also the “what could have been” factor. If the stock price stagnates, both options might wither away without coming into play, making the trader ponder over potential gains they might have bagged had they opted for a different strategy.

When Should Protective Collars Be Used?

The stock market’s inherent unpredictability often necessitates a safety harness. In such times, the protective collar becomes an essential strategic shield. Recognizing the optimal moments to employ it is crucial for maximizing its benefits. For example, in the face of macroeconomic or geopolitical uncertainty—especially now as tension continues to build amidst the Israel-Hamas war—the market could potentially enter a tailspin. 

In these uncertain times, a protective collar acts as a safety net, minimizing potential downturns. Similarly, corporate announcements and earnings reports like PayPals upcoming release are defining moments that can either send stocks skyrocketing or plummeting. A protective collar becomes particularly handy here, allowing investors to navigate these unpredictable waters with a bit more assurance.

Moreover, in the world of options, decisions about when to “sell to open” versus when to “sell to close” can be pivotal. This nuance reflects whether an investor is initiating a new position or closing an existing one. A protective collar can be an instrumental strategy in such decisions, ensuring that investors are optimally positioned.

Another strategic use of the protective collar comes into play for those who’ve witnessed significant growth in their investments but aren’t ready to sell. This strategy lets them lock in their gains without actually parting with the stock, offering a clever sidestep from potential capital gains tax. This becomes especially relevant in volatile sectors like tech, where the highs and lows can be equally extreme. Here, a protective collar acts much like a safety harness for a tightrope walker, ensuring balance during the chaos.

For those deeply committed to their stocks with a long-term vision, the short-term market jitters can be disconcerting. A protective collar can serve as a buffer against these temporary market tremors, keeping the investor’s long-term perspective intact.

In essence, the protective collar isn’t a universal remedy but a tool requiring judicious use. Its effectiveness lies in understanding its applicability in distinct scenarios. Instead of being merely a reactionary measure, it can be a proactive strategy, arming investors against the whims and fancies of a constantly evolving market.


Navigating the unpredictable terrains of the stock market, a protective collar serves as a tactical shield, balancing risk mitigation with profit potential. Its strength lies in offering investors a safety net against significant market downturns while preserving room for upside growth.

Even though protective collars are a powerful financial armor, they’re not bulletproof. For those who want to add another protective layer to their strategy, many consider bolstering their strategy with options trade signals. This way you’re even more protected, and stay ahead of market shifts.

While this strategy exemplifies the delicate art of prudent investing—juggling risk and reward—it’s paramount for traders to understand its workings. Employed with discernment in line with market dynamics and individual investment preferences, a protective collar transitions from just being a strategy to a tangible asset, enabling investors to turn market uncertainties into structured growth and stability opportunities.

Deciphering the Protective Collar: FAQs

What Are the Key Elements of a Protective Collar?

A protective collar involves three primary components: owning the underlying stock, buying an out-of-the-money (OTM) put option, and selling an out-of-the-money (OTM) call option – not to be confused with selling a put and buying a call. The owned stock provides the fundamental investment position. The purchased put option serves as a protective measure, setting a floor on potential losses. Simultaneously, the sold call option not only helps offset the cost of the put option but also caps the potential profit.

How Does the Protective Collar Strategy Reduce Risk?

A protective collar limits risk by using a put option to set a floor on the stock’s potential decline. If the stock price drops, the put option becomes more valuable, compensating for the stock’s loss. This ensures that even if the stock’s price plummets, the investor’s loss is limited to the difference between the stock’s initial price and the put option’s strike price.

Are There Any Drawbacks to Using a Protective Collar?

While a protective collar minimizes downside risk, it also caps the upside potential due to the sold call option. If the stock’s price rises significantly, the investor will not fully benefit from the increase, as the sold call option may be exercised by the buyer, capping the stock’s selling price at the call option’s strike price. Additionally, there is the cost of the put option premium, although this is often offset by the premium received from selling the call option.

Can I Use a Protective Collar with Any Stock?

A: In theory, a protective collar can be applied to any type of stock. However, it is most effective for stocks with high volatility, as the strategy aims to mitigate downside risk while still allowing for some upside potential.

How Does the Protective Collar Differ from Other Hedging Techniques?

The protective collar stands out because it distinctly offers both a ceiling for gains and a floor for potential losses. This differentiates it from strategies such as the covered call, which only provides upside protection, the married put that solely provides downside security, or the protective call strategy which leans towards safeguarding a short stock position by buying a call option. By integrating aspects of both a covered call and a married put, the protective collar presents a balanced approach to risk management in options trading.